American vs Icelandair
On the best documented aircraft, American scores 10/10 for the business seat and Icelandair 0/10. The aircraft on your booking decides whether those seats apply.
By Jon Miksis · comparison updated
This page contains affiliate links. If you sign up or book through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend, or the order we recommend it in. Full disclosure.
What matters for your booking
Business fares
Of 34 shared business routes, American was cheaper on 0, Icelandair on 34, and 0 were the same price.
Economy fares
Of 38 shared economy routes, American was cheaper on 9, Icelandair on 29, and 0 were the same price.
Start with your route and cabin. A fare advantage in economy does not establish a business-class bargain, and a better seat does not establish that a connection or a higher fare is worth it for your trip.
The business seats being compared
These are each airline’s best-scoring documented business aircraft. The fare grid does not identify aircraft, so the seat below is not promised with any fare in the table. Service and food require a separate firsthand review.
American
787-9P (Flagship Suite)
- Seat layout
- 1-2-1
- Fully flat bed
- Yes
- Direct aisle access at every seat
- Yes
- Privacy door
- Yes
- Seat score
- 10/10
- Wi-Fi
- Paid in the recorded product
- Lounge access
- Included in the recorded fare
- Checked bags
- 2
Cabin checked .
Recorded source: American Flagship Suite launch coverage, AeroLOPA aa-789p seat map.
Icelandair
737 MAX / 757 (Saga Premium)
- Seat layout
- 2-2
- Fully flat bed
- No
- Direct aisle access at every seat
- No
- Privacy door
- No
- Seat score
- 0/10
- Wi-Fi
- Paid in the recorded product
- Lounge access
- Included in the recorded fare
- Checked bags
- 2
Cabin checked .
Recorded source: Icelandair fare-type pages, Saga Premium reviews.
Seat scores describe bed, aisle access and privacy door only. Read the scoring method. A tie does not compare comfort, food, service or reliability.
Check the aircraft on American
787-9P (Flagship Suite): 10/10 for the seat. Flagship Suite launched June 2025 and flies only on newly delivered 787-9Ps. Every other American widebody keeps the door-less reverse-herringbone Flagship Business. Recorded September 1, 2026.
777-300ER / 787 (Flagship Business): 8/10 for the seat. Reverse herringbone, direct aisle access from every seat, no privacy door. Recorded September 1, 2026.
Compare the fares and the routing
Each row compares the same airports, cabin, travel dates and observation date. It can still compare a nonstop against a connection. Journey times, aircraft, baggage allowances and change rules were not recorded with these fares; check those before treating the price difference as a saving.
Showing 12 of 34 matched business routes. Round trip per person in USD, for travel November 8–14, 2026.
| Route and observation date | American | Icelandair | Price difference |
|---|---|---|---|
New York (JFK) → Barcelona (BCN) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $8,411Nonstop | $2,290Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $6,121 less |
New York (JFK) → Paris Charles de Gaulle (CDG) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $5,945Nonstop | $2,336Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $3,609 less |
New York (JFK) → London Heathrow (LHR) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $6,047Nonstop | $2,338Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $3,709 less |
Orlando (MCO) → Dublin (DUB) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $9,425Connects via PHL | $2,434Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $6,991 less |
Orlando (MCO) → Barcelona (BCN) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $5,476Connects via MIA | $2,648Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $2,828 less |
Orlando (MCO) → Rome Fiumicino (FCO) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $7,301Connects via PHL | $2,662Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $4,639 less |
Denver (DEN) → Barcelona (BCN) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $8,854Connects via DFW | $2,692Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $6,162 less |
Orlando (MCO) → Zurich (ZRH) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $10,044Connects via PHL | $2,764Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $7,280 less |
Orlando (MCO) → Munich (MUC) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $13,575Connects via CLT | $2,844Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $10,731 less |
Chicago (ORD) → Paris Charles de Gaulle (CDG) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $10,366Nonstop | $2,852Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $7,514 less |
Boston (BOS) → London Heathrow (LHR) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $6,617Nonstop | $2,913Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $3,704 less |
Boston (BOS) → Barcelona (BCN) Observed September 1, 2026 Compare all observed airlines | $5,795Connects via JFK | $3,016Connects via KEF | Icelandair was $2,779 less |
Your airport missing? Check the full route tool for the airlines we observed there. Confirm current fares, journey time, baggage and ticket rules before booking.
Before paying for the ticket
- Check the exact operating airline and seat map on every long flight, including the return. An airline name or business-class label alone does not guarantee a flat bed or aisle access.
- Compare total journey time and connection length. A lower fare may buy a much longer trip.
- Reprice with your bags, preferred seats and change rules included. These observations do not establish that the tickets have identical restrictions.
- Check other airlines on the route. Being cheaper than the other airline on this page does not establish the cheapest fare in the market.
Common questions
- Is American or Icelandair better in business class to Europe?
- On the best documented aircraft, American scores 10/10 for the business seat and Icelandair 0/10. The aircraft on your booking decides whether those seats apply. Of 34 shared business routes, American was cheaper on 0, Icelandair on 34, and 0 were the same price. Service and food are not scored in this comparison. These are observations for travel November 8–14, 2026, not current quotes.
- Which is cheaper, American or Icelandair?
- Of 34 shared business routes, American was cheaper on 0, Icelandair on 34, and 0 were the same price. Of 38 shared economy routes, American was cheaper on 9, Icelandair on 29, and 0 were the same price. Both counts refer to travel November 8–14, 2026. A cheaper fare may involve a connection; compare the itinerary as well as the price.
- Will I get the business seat shown here?
- These cards describe the named aircraft in our cabin records, not a seat guaranteed on every flight. At least one of these airlines has a recorded aircraft or cabin variation. Check the operating airline, seat map and aircraft for every segment before paying; equipment can change. The fare observations do not record the aircraft.
- Has Jon flown these business cabins?
- American business class is not on Jon’s confirmed flown roster. Icelandair business class is not on Jon’s confirmed flown roster. That records the airline and cabin, not every aircraft or itinerary. This page compares documented specifications and dated fares.
Join the Club, free
One email a week: the Europe fares worth acting on, the new transatlantic routes, and first look at the tools. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.